Episode Transcript
STEVE: Hello, and welcome to another episode of the PPI 101 Podcast Series, sponsored by the Merrill Center for Family Wealth. My name is Steve Legler, and I'm delighted to be your host once again. In this episode, we're going to be looking into the subject of multidisciplinary advising as it relates to Purposeful Planning for family clients. We'll get into what we mean by multidisciplinary advising, why it matters to PPI members, how it works, and where this idea fits into how we can better serve our clients. Our guest is Judi Cunningham, a family enterprise consultant and educator who's been involved with PPI for many years in a governance capacity, but whom I got to know over a decade ago when I enrolled in the Family Enterprise Advisor program in one of their Toronto cohorts. Judi was the founder of that program and still teaches in it today. According to their website, the program is for professional advisors from a wide range of disciplines who have significant technical knowledge and are looking to add to their skill set to better serve their family enterprise clients. I had decided that Judi would be the perfect guest for the episode on this subject before reading that, but I'm even more convinced now. Judi Cunningham, thanks so much for being our guest today.
JUDI: Thank you, Steve. It's a pleasure to be here and talk about something that I'm very passionate about.
STEVE: Indeed, you are. So let's just start with what do we mean when we put those words together, multidisciplinary advice? What are we talking about?
JUDI: Well, I think fundamentally what we're talking about is that there's a requirement, in working with high-net-worth and ultra-high-net-worth families, families that have collective wealth or businesses, for a whole variety of help and support from different types of advisors and different disciplines. Multidisciplinary advising is getting help from all these different disciplines.
STEVE: Okay, so their families are being served by a variety of professionals. What happens if those professionals just stay in their silos? Then I guess the family is stuck in the position of understanding how they all fit together.
JUDI: Yeah, that's actually one of the biggest problems in serving families. Families become like the general contractor, where they've got all these people working for them, and they have to then figure out, A: who they're going to listen to; B: what the right advice or the best advice for the moment is; and C: whether it's integrated advice. That's probably the biggest issue: Is it integrated? Is the tax advice integrated with the estate advice, the investment advice, the business advice, and so on? That's one of the biggest challenges that I see in serving clients.
STEVE: And the families then are stuck trying to make sense of it all.
JUDI: That's right.
STEVE: Some of them don't mind being in that position because they think they're really good at it, maybe not as good as they need to be. And others abhor it and don't know how to then decide, like you said, who to listen to.
JUDI: Yeah. Well, I think that sometimes it's not about what the best advice is. It's just that they don't know how all these pieces fit together. Their advisory team is like a very carefully crafted web or puzzle, and there's only puzzle pieces. It's like doing a puzzle, and there are all these gaps in the puzzle, and you've lost pieces. So what happens is there does require a certain level of coordination of advice in order to create a nice, finished puzzle with all the pieces in their place.
STEVE: So, to have a coherent plan, you need to have people who understand how the different pieces of the puzzle go together.
JUDI: Yeah.
STEVE: And I love the puzzle analogy as well. I often talk about how you're trying to put the puzzle together, but you don't have the picture on the box.
JUDI: Yeah. Yeah. Really.
STEVE: And even advisors, that's what makes this work so difficult. You have to rely on the other people on the multidisciplinary team. So why does this subject matter so much to PPI members?
JUDI: I think it matters because what I always say to advisors when I'm working with them is that we are all absolutely necessary. Every single one of us in our disciplines, and there are some people who work in this field who are highly, highly specialized. So we're all necessary, but none of us are sufficient. There's not one advisor who can do everything that's required for a family, and so it matters a lot to learn how to collaborate and to be willing to collaborate. I also think that one of the hard things is that some advisors don't like playing nice with other advisors. Sometimes they're like, "I think my advice is better or more important," or, "This piece is more important than that piece, so I think I should be at the top of the heap." So I think that learning how to coordinate advice is really important for advisors, as well as learning how they listen to one another and defer to each other. I think this is one of the hardest things I've learned in my career of working with other advisors for so long. There are things that I'm like, "I don't know how to do that," so I just need to defer to the people who are much smarter than me around those particular topics. That's hard sometimes for people to do.
STEVE: Yeah, because everyone wants to feel important in front of their client, and somehow, for some people, not being the most important person anymore is the real ego blow that they don't want to have in front of their clients. So it's one of the things where people are competing for who's the most important.
JUDI: Sometimes. I don't think it's all the time, but certainly, I do think that sometimes people are trying to be. There's a term in our field. Often, people go, "Well, who's the quarterback?" And sometimes I'm loath to even use that term because it's this desire to be first among equals, right? We're all doing this thing, but I'm the quarterback, and so I'm the lead horse here. I'm going to be driving this whole thing forward and coordinating everything. So, on the one hand, I actually agree that there needs to be coordination around advice, but I do get a little worried sometimes when people are trying to vie for that position. Somehow, it's a better position. I'm more inclined to think that at different times in an engagement, there needs to be different people taking the quarterback role. Sometimes one advisor is going to be in that role, and then, at other times in an engagement, another advisor might take on the quarterback role. I'm working with a client right now. Our team is based on this multidisciplinary approach. I work with a CPA who is extremely talented around estates, tax, and all the technical estate stuff. So we're pulling together a presentation for the client. I might be the lead advisor on this client, but in this case, I am the least important because that's not what I do. So I'm working really closely with him, saying, "Well, that stuff's really good, and we need to be thoughtful about how we're going to integrate that into the family, and what's that going to mean for the family, and how complex is it? Will they be able to understand some of this stuff? Because none of them are trained in this area, so will it be too complicated for them? And how do we think about what we're presenting, but also how we're presenting it?" So it's a very coordinated activity. I'm not behind the scenes, but I'm certainly more like I'm listening more, and this other person is taking the lead on it.
STEVE: I'm not surprised that we've delved into the area of, or are getting to the area of, the difference between the content and the process. Many of the specialists are specialists in content. There are other people who are listening for how the client will actually understand this, absorb this, and integrate it into their family. And who's going to take care to make sure that happens properly? That's part of, I guess, what my question was: Why does it matter to PPI members? It's because we have people from so many different disciplines, for sure, and understanding how to dance well with each other and take turns taking the lead when it makes more sense for someone else to do it is probably a huge part of the attraction to joining a group like PPI. It's about meeting people from these other domains to understand them better because isn't that part of being able to deal with other people: understanding why they do the things they do the way they do them?
JUDI: Absolutely. I think that learning, one of the things that I love about PPI is listening to all the different advisors. Not every advisor is created equal. If you meet an accountant, it's not like every accountant is identical, or every family therapist, or every lawyer, or whatever it is. Each person has a different approach to the work that they do, so it is very useful to dig in. I get really curious about different disciplines and ask, "Well, how do you do what you do, and how does this work?" I was just in a meeting the other day with a private bank, and I was like, "Okay, so what is the perfect client for you guys? When is the handoff? At what point is the handoff so important?" Because I think that the extent to which we can understand each other is the extent to which clients are getting really good advice. Families are getting really good advice, and if we don't fully understand each other, then the clients are the ones who are going to suffer because we're not helping them to the best of our ability with all these different disciplines.
STEVE: We have to be really focusing on how the client is receiving all of the input, which sometimes can be overlooked. So one of the general questions was, how does this work? How does multidisciplinary advising work? But I've added another question to that: Why is it so difficult?
JUDI: Well, I think, as I've mentioned, inside my own company, we're a multidisciplinary team. That's the easier thing because I work with these people all the time. I know how they think. I know how they function. There's no jockeying for control. We're very collaborative. All that stuff. Where it starts to get more complicated is that, in addition to that, we work really closely with our clients' advisors, their wealth advisors, their tax advisors, their estate specialists, etc. We work really closely with them because we don't do any planning work. So it works by everybody talking to everybody else and making sure the right people are at the table at the right time. Sometimes we're meeting with these advisors separately from the client to make sure that when the client is in the room, everything is clear amongst us as advisors. So I think that's a really important piece. Why it's difficult is that there are so many moving parts that you can't always anticipate. It's just the level of complexity that goes on, whether it's cross-border issues, estate planning issues, or all of what we call the soft side, all the relationship issues that are going on. That makes it really complex when you bring in all these different disciplines. I was just sitting in a client meeting, and after the client had left, one of the advisors was saying, "Well, I think this is going on, and I think this is going on," and making all these assumptions. I was listening and thinking, "Hmm, that's interesting. I did not get that from that meeting at all." So that's the other thing that makes this really complex: We leave these meetings, and we're not just doing this. To your point around content and process, we're not just going and executing on a bunch of technical elements. We're managing the complexity of relationships and what's actually going on at a process level, and that sometimes is really hard to navigate.
STEVE: You were mentioning, Judi, that in your own firm, it's less complicated. But I guess most of the PPI members come from firms where there are people who do what they do, and now they're meeting people at PPI Rendezvous who are from something else. If they're going to then work together, they have to overcome a number of challenges to do that.
JUDI: Yeah. First off, I would say the very first thing is that people have to want to and be willing to collaborate. Collaboration isn't easy for everyone, but it's such a rewarding thing to do. I can't even imagine. I don't think I would ever work with a client on my own again in my entire career. First of all, it's way too hard. Second of all, it's not nearly as fulfilling for me, and I certainly don't think it's as fulfilling for the client. But if I could just be selfish for a moment and think about myself, it's so much more fun when you collaborate. But it does take commitment to learn how people work, and it can be clunky in the early days of collaboration. If you and I started working on a client together, and we're in the same meeting, and you start taking one road while I start going down another, I'm like, "Whoa, that's not where I wanted to go." So it can be uncomfortable, and it requires us to debrief afterward and say, "Here's where I was trying to go, and we didn't really get to go there. So in the next meeting, I'd like to do that," and you might say, "Sure, fine." In a lot of cases, people go, "Oh, I didn't realize," or, "I'm sorry." Or, in the meeting, you say, "Listen, that's great. I'd like to go back to this." So you can do it elegantly and easily, but it's sometimes awkward. Sometimes people get annoyed because they're going down a track that they want to pursue, and then somebody tries to go somewhere else, and it's like, "I don't like this."
STEVE: I was doing my thing until you came and got me distracted.
ANDY: Exactly.
STEVE: So learning to work together is almost like learning to dance together, and you're going to step on each other's toes a few times. But once you've danced with the person for a while and you know how to do it, that's when it gets even much more rewarding.
JUDI: Yes. It does.
STEVE: I jotted down why it's so difficult. It's because we're doing this work for humans, and we are all humans trying to do it.
JUDI: There you go.
STEVE: When AI takes over the world, this will all be resolved when the computers talk to each other.
JUDI: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
STEVE: So where does this fit in the world of PPI? How can we help people do this better?
JUDI: Well, I think that it sits at the center of the relationship. I think that's where it really sits, and it really sits at the center. How do we help people do it better? I think getting people to really think about: A: do they want to collaborate? B: if they want to do their very best for a client, I don't think it's really a choice on our part. I think we really have to collaborate. I really do. I'm really firm on this belief system that says I just don't think people who go out there and work on their own are doing the best service for their clients. If we adopted that mindset, I think it would make it easy for us to collaborate because if I fundamentally believe it's better for the client, then even if I'm working with somebody who might annoy me, I might say, "Well, listen, this is their tax advisor or whoever, and they have something to bring to the table, and so do I. How do we come together to provide the very best advice?" The other thing that I think is really required here is an effort made by the advisory team to work out their relationships. We are asking clients to work on their relationships in their families. We're asking them to do all kinds of things.
STEVE: Yep.
JUDI: I think it's my responsibility to do the same thing on my side of the equation because I feel like we're moving in parallel to our clients. We have a team over here that needs to work out our stuff. So if we're struggling or not being able to get along, that's my job to work that out. I need to talk to that person or those people and make sure that we figure out our relationship.
STEVE: And that's extra work, and that's not always time you can bill the client for either. That's one of the challenges: We have to be realistic about what needs to be done for the client. But as you're saying, the rewards for doing this are all over the place. It's better for the client. It's better for the advisors. It's better for everybody in the system. I think where it fits is that the good news is, I think the people who join PPI and come to Rendezvous and other learning circles and things like that kind of self-select as the type of people who do want to collaborate. But the idea of saying that it's mandatory that you collaborate.
JUDI: Yeah.
STEVE: I think that could be a mantra for PPI. If you're here, it's because you're coming to collaborate, and I don't think that would be a hard sell.
JUDI: Yeah. Well, I look at how collaborative the people are who come into PPI. It's incredible. But I want to go back to something that you said around how it can be expensive to collaborate. When we work with clients, we assume that we will be collaborating. All of our contracts are built with the collaboration piece included because we know that we're going to be spending a certain number of hours and time in the collaboration process that won't even have the client in the mix. Behind the scenes, we're doing a lot of meetings without the clients. We're meeting with some of their advisors. We may be asking them if we can reach out to different people in their system. We know that is going to happen, so we build it into our contracts. They know that, so they expect it from us.
STEVE: So it requires a different business model than for people who are otherwise charging on an hourly rate.
JUDI: That's right.
STEVE: But building that in, figuring that out, and going into it with the assumption that this is the default, this is how we do it, means there will be that. If you're clear on all that from the get-go with the client, it shouldn't be a problem.
JUDI: Yeah. I also think that clients understand this. Do they want to pay for a bunch of stuff that they don't want, just kind of fluffy extra stuff? No, they don't. However, when they understand, they'll say, "Okay, I get that you need to talk to these different people in my system, and I get that I'm paying you and them at the same time that you're talking to them. I understand that, and I understand the value." It is my job, or our job as advisors, to help them understand why we would want to talk to these people and how it's helpful to them, not just to me. Is it helpful for me? It is, but it's ultimately helpful for them.
STEVE: Right. In the end, it's probably going to save them money by not having to redo things because the advisors didn't bother to check with each other and make sure that what one person was doing was coherent with what the other person was doing.
JUDI: Yeah, for sure.
STEVE: I think the other thing about PPI, where this fits, is that I think we all want to try and do this better. It's really hard to work with people for the first time, and you don't even know if they're someone you would want to dance with. But coming together and being members of PPI helps. There was a webinar a little while back where people were talking about referring to other people they knew from the PPI network. One of the people mentioned, "Oh yeah, I got three referrals last year, but it was someone that I had known for eight years, someone I'd known for 10 years, and someone I'd known for 13 years." So I think you can't show up one time and say, "Well, I didn't get any referrals," and then forget it. This is a long road, and it means spending time with each other.
JUDI: Yeah, for sure. I think about when I refer business, it takes me a long time to make a referral. A referral is like I'm endorsing somebody, so I'm not just going to send them to anybody. If there's somebody I don't know personally, I will say, "I don't know this person. I don't know of them other than that I know they do this, so I can't vouch for the quality of their work. All I know is they do it. So you can talk to them. Feel free to talk to them, but I can't vouch for whether they're good at what they do."
STEVE: And getting to know people in our community is probably the most satisfying way to get to know people well enough to think that you would be willing to refer them.
JUDI: Yeah, yeah. One of the things I wanted to mention, Steve, was the act of putting together a multidisciplinary charter. One of the things that I think is really helpful is that, in the program you were talking about, we have people actually create a multidisciplinary charter, which is essentially a way of establishing how we are going to interact with each other and how things are going to be handled. Even if we don't do something as formal as a charter, you can have an open dialogue around questions like: How will this work? Who will be coordinating with the client? Will it be both of us or just one of us? How will communication go? If they send you an email, are you going to copy everyone? We have a client where one of the lead advisors on this client only receives emails from the client, and then she always copies the team. The client only sends it to her, and then she always copies the team. It's pretty funny, actually. I don't know why they don't want to send it to everybody.
STEVE: Well, this is a lot of hard work to do to do it well. And I think we all want to do it better all the time, and that's why we joined PPI. Judi, this has been a great discussion. I think we did a pretty good job of covering this subject from a one-on-one perspective. So when PPI members hear us talk about multidisciplinary advising, I think they'll now have a better understanding of why it matters, how it works, and where it fits. Thanks so much for joining me here today, Judi. I couldn't have done it without you.
JUDI: My pleasure, Steve. It's always fun to have a conversation with you. So thank you for inviting me.
STEVE: Listeners, we hope you got something useful out of this conversation. If so, please don't keep it to yourselves. I look forward to being with you again soon in future episodes. I'm Steve Legler. Thanks for listening. Until next time.